Aurelio's Pizza Of Crown Point Information

If you're on the hunt for a local pizza spot that balances classic flavors with a welcoming neighborhood vibe, Aurelio's Pizza Of Crown Point at 1900 N Main St, Crown Point, IN 46307, United States, is a place worth checking out. Stepping inside, you immediately notice the casual, friendly atmosphere that makes it easy to settle in whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a full meal with family. The menu offers a broad selection of pizzas, ranging from traditional thin-crust options to specialty pies loaded with inventive toppings, all baked to a golden perfection with a crust that's satisfyingly crisp yet tender. Beyond pizza, there are hearty pasta dishes, fresh salads, and a handful of sandwiches that cater to both kids and adults, making it a versatile spot for varied appetites. Regular diners often rave about the personal touch from the staff, noting that servers are attentive without being intrusive and always ready to recommend a favorite slice or a pairing from the drink menu. The restaurant's local relevance shows through its consistent use of quality ingredients and its reputation for dependable service, which has kept patrons coming back for years. Even during busy evenings, the pace rarely feels rushed, allowing you to enjoy your meal at a comfortable tempo. Parking near the location is straightforward, and the open layout inside accommodates both small groups and larger gatherings without feeling cramped. Reviewers frequently highlight the value for money, pointing out that generous portions and flavorful combinations make it a satisfying choice for casual dining. Whether you’re popping in for a quick lunch or lingering over dinner with friends, Aurelio's Pizza Of Crown Point combines solid culinary craftsmanship with a cozy, approachable environment that feels like a genuine neighborhood favorite.

Most Popular Dishes

Chicken Parmesan $14.50

Grilled or breaded boneless breast of chicken baked mozzarella cheese and marinara sauce served over your choice of spaghetti, mostaccioli or fettuccini pasta. Served with small diner salad (Fresh and crisp iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with tomato, cucumber, red onion, diced red peppers, and croutons

Chicken Alfredo $14.50

Grilled or breaded boneless breast of chicken covered with a rich creamy cheese sauce served over your choice of spaghetti, mostaccioli or fettuccini pasta. Served with small diner salad (Fresh and crisp iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with tomato, cucumber, red onion, diced red peppers, and croutons

Homemade Meatball Sandwich $7.49

Aurelio's homemade Italian style meatballs smothered in red sauce and served on toasted Italian bread

Aurelio's Italian Submarine Sandwich $7.99

The original! Imported ham, salami and Italian beef, topped with mozzarella cheese and baked to perfection with shredded lettuce and house dressing

Dinner Salad $

Fresh and crisp Iceberg and Romaine lettuce topped with tomato, cucumber, red onion, diced red peppers, and croutons

Aurelio's Italian Antipasto Salad $

A bed of lettuce topped with ham, mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, green & black olives, sweet red peppers & pepperoncini. House dressing recommended

Soft Bread Sticks $

Four soft bread sticks seasoned with our special garlic seasoning, topped with Romano cheese, served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping

Cheese Sticks $

Six breaded Italian mozzarella cheese sticks served with a side of marinara sauce for dipping

Full Menu

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

Love their food and dining room is so cozy. We always enjoy dining with our family

My boyfriend and I come here about once a month. We love their pizza. This visit we tried the stuffed pizza. Oh my gosh it was the best we have eaten. I really do recommend the stuffed pizza. We thought it was a stuffed crust, and when it came we couldn't believe how delicious it looked and tasted. Almost kind of like a Chicago style deep dish except the only differences it's not a deep dish. We really do recommend trying this pizza it's absolutely delicious!

Took a night vacation fom Illinois and ordered delivery to Hilton Garden Inn Merrillville and the pizza came HOT AND FRESH like it was fresh from the oven! Delivery was fast and delivery driver was so sweet! Great pizza!! So glad to have an Aurelio's in Crown Point!!

Aurelio's is a nice place. Our server was very helpful. There are six beautiful handmade glass art pieces hanging on the back of some booths. Aurelio's menu tells about it's start in the 1950s with homemade food. It's a far cry from homemade now (Bosco sticks, fried onion rings, mozzarella sticks are certainly shipped frozen from big name companies) but the food isn't bad whatsoever. It's just typical. Dependable. If you're a pizza fan who enjoys hot meatball sandwiches and French fries, you'll like this place. Kids probably enjoy it. No dessert was available on our night.

Ordered 3 deep dish pizzas (a cheese, a sausage/pepperoni, and a spinach/mushroom/garlic). All 3 were baked to perfection. The crust is golden and buttery. Each bite has been perfection. Remember to ask for red pepper flakes if you don't have any--chef's kiss. Several of the younger kids thought the sauce-on-top looked yucky but they eventually gave them a try and loved them. Every single one of the picky eater kids are now deep dish lovers. Thanks!!

I got the sausage and cheese pizza with black olives. Very Good pizza but the main downside is that the buffet is only open on Tuesday after 4pm and the dining room is only open early on weekends at 11am. Orders before 4pm are mostly carryout.

Let me start of by saying that in from New York City, home of the best pizzas and I’m visiting Indiana. Aurelio’s pizza is one of THE BEST pizzerias I have ever had in my life, including comparing to NY pizza . I think I love Aurelio’s more than Lou Malnatis. This will be my number one pizzeria when I come to Indiana . A++++++++!!!!

Got a large pepperoni and sausage pizza. The tasty toppings covered the pizza. The sauce did not taste of tomato paste, like other places. Just tomatoes like it should be. We are new to CP, and this is the best we've found so far. We will be back to eat here again.

Aurelio's Pizza Of Crown Point